Romancing the Buddha
Back to home

Holiday Identity Crisis

by Michael Lisagor

With an American Jewish heritage, a Buddhist practice and two young daughters, what holidays to celebrate in 1987 became an important question.

it was early Christmas morning And all over my house, Not a creature was stirring, Not even a mouse. I tiptoed downstairs past the First sunlight beam, Took a look at our family room And let out a scream! My daughters came running, My wife tumbled out. Together they queried me . . . Why such a shout? We have both a menorah and Christmas tree, I cried. Oh, oh, said my family, his Brain must be fried. It's not my brain I insisted, But something we missed. Something to do with being A Buddhist. I know what it isn't, but I'm not Sure what it is. And so we decided To get down to biz. We searched through Nichiren's letters And Daisaku Ikeda's writings, And tried to reach a consensus With a minimum of fighting. As we chanted, I thought What an emotional issue, But I'll bet our faith deepens Before we are through.

December has always been a confusing time of year for me. Both my wife and I have a Jewish heritage and, especially for her, Hanukkah has been a significant holiday. I, on the other hand, have always been a sucker for Christmas. I love the tree, the stockings, the eggnog, the songs, the eggnog (did I mention eggnog?).

Our daughters have had different feelings depending on their age. But, in general, I'd have to say they like the presents—both giving and receiving—especially when Hanukkah arrived in early December and they made out like bandits!

They still love leaving cookies and milk for Santa Claus, even though they know I'm trying not to gain weight. Myself, I'm partial to mistletoe; I carry it around with me in case I unexpectedly run into my wife.

This holiday confusion is especially perplexing to my children. Friends who most likely celebrate Hanukkah or Christmas surround them at school. Of course, my daughters realize that we celebrate our joy of life with morning and evening chanting, but that's tough to explain to a group of classmates. And many of our family's social relationships in December, both through work and home, center on holiday activities. Avoiding them doesn't seem consistent with practicing Buddhism in our daily lives. Actually, it seems more like narrow mindedness.

The most relevant Buddhist concept we uncovered to assist in solving our holiday dilemma was a precept called "adapting to local customs." According to The Soka Gakkai Dictionary of Buddhism, it means, "In matters the Buddha did not expressly either permit or forbid, one may act in accordance with local custom, so long as the fundamental principles of Buddhism are not violated."

So, there must be a difference between the religious and cultural significance of the holiday season. We decided that this would be our barometer in judging the appropriateness of our holiday activities. Let me add that I don't believe this is a black and white issue. After all, faith is a lifetime journey. So, each year, our perspective of ourselves as Buddhists changes. Some traditions that we have previously adhered to may now seem inappropriate while others are deemed acceptable.

Buddhism talks about the Middle Way. I think we have an obligation to our children to teach them the importance of achieving a balance in their lives. It must be difficult for a child to grow up without having experienced the warmth and fun of a holiday season. On the other hand, an overabundance of materialism that so often accompanies December can also be misleading.

Last night at dinner, our family decided not to have a Christmas tree this year but to fill small stockings on Christmas instead. We'll keep the Jewish menorah during Hanukkah for its cultural significance and because the girls enjoy lighting candles. We also resolved to fill December with helping others through our Buddhist, family, school, and work activities.

Above on our rooftop, Several reindeer hoofs pounded. We gathered around our altar As the prayer bell sounded. The four of us huddled— World peace seemed so near. And to all—a good night And a life full of cheer.

Back to home

This article was included in Romancing the Buddha. Read the full book free as a Flipbook or find more essays by challenge.