Romancing the Buddha
Back to home

Dinner at Bea's — Part Two

by Michael Lisagor

The Benefit of the Doubt

Dinner at Bea's—Part Two

Illustrations by Larry Ashton

Benefits should be distributed a bit at a time in order that they may be savored fully. — Niccolo Machiavelli from The Prince

The street outside the diner was buried in more than a foot of snow. A couple in their late thirties sat together in the last booth just as they had every Friday night for the past three months. Bea, the elderly owner, server, and cashier, smiled to herself as she washed some spilled coffee off the yellowed Formica counter. A battered wife in her youth, Bea was unusually protective of other women. But even she had to admit that the man, Paul, seemed to have a much-needed positive effect on the young lady.

Bea thought her name was Kate. Funny, she referred to most women as "gals." For some reason, Kate was a lady. Must be the way she dresses, she mused. Watching them through the wall mirrors behind the old soda fountain, she wondered what they found to talk about for hours on end. She occasionally listened in on their conversations.

There were five booths along a picture window. An old string of faded colored Christmas lights twinkled across the top. "Gonna have to take those down," Bea thought.

Paul and Kate were sitting in the farthest booth from the door. There were also eight empty swivel stools covered in yellow plastic at the counter across from the booths. Frank, the white-haired cook and dishwasher, could be seen through an opening in the wall as he grilled hamburgers for the two customers. The burgers barely resembled meat but the regulars loved them. Frank Sinatra, no relation to the cook, sang softly from a tabletop jukebox, a selection from a previous customer.

Bea remembered the first night Paul and Kate had met. She hadn't really expected to see them together again. Their first encounter had been tumultuous to say the least…intense talking by Paul punctuated with fits of yelling and a tearful visit to the bathroom by Kate. But they returned a week later and appeared, from the fact they were sitting on the same side of the table, to have made significant progress in their relationship. The streetlights outside flickered behind the falling snow.

There is a Scottish saying that if you remain silent, it will be to your disadvantage. It is far more enjoyable and beneficial to open-heartedly develop dialogue with others than to maintain a lonely silence. — Daisaku Ikeda

"I don't understand why you don't call Susan. Not talking isn't going to solve anything."

Paul loved the way Kate waved her hands around when she spoke. "I've tried, Kate. Honest. She doesn't want to hear from me. We only just got close in the last few years."

"Well," Kate replied, "I suppose I can't blame her. After all, you did insult her boyfriend and her doctor in the same evening."

"Gee, thanks for the support." Paul fidgeted with the straw in his diet Coke.

"Sorry, I didn't mean that…I mean what I meant was…"

"To be mean, that's what you meant!" Paul looked forlorn. Kate looked amused. Bea looked away.

"You know, Paul," Kate said, "This is the first time since we met that I've actually seen you look discouraged. What happened…lose your favorite set of prayer beads?" Although Kate had started chanting, her practice was tenuous and she enjoyed teasing Paul over the intensity of his faith.

"Problems are a part of the practice," Paul replied somewhat defensively.

"I prefer the benefits."

"Well, so do I. But my biggest benefits always seem to follow major obstacles. Believe me, if I could just pass go and collect my two hundred dollars without the suffering, I would!"

"And how," muttered Bea from behind the counter.

Both Paul and Kate looked over at her, but she busied herself placing pickles and potato chips on their platters before bringing them to their table. They ate their meal in silence for a while. Wiping some ketchup from her mouth with her napkin, Kate reached into her large cloth purse and withdrew a newspaper clipping.

"Uh, oh," Paul cried. "Last time you did this we argued for more than two hours. Maybe I'd better order another dinner. I might need the energy." He laughed. She grimaced.

"Look," she said. "You told me to study and so I just thought you might want to hear this. If you'd rather not..."

"I'm sorry," Paul said apologetically. "Please, go ahead. I was just kidding."

Kate put on her reading glasses (he thought they made her eyes look even more beautiful). She read, "Whether we regard difficulties in life as misfortunes or whether we view them as good fortune depends entirely on how much we have forged our inner determination. It all depends on our attitude, our inner state of life."

Paul encouraged her to continue reading.

"With a dauntless spirit, we can lead a cheerful and thoroughly enjoyable life. We can develop a 'self' of such fortitude that we look forward to life's trials and tribulations with a sense of profound elation and joy." I thought it might be encouraging to you since you seem to be struggling with accepting your sister's illness."

"Yeah. You know, I think I'm mostly just mad at myself for chewing out her boyfriend."

"Well, he is her doctor."

"Yeah, I know. But he's so arrogant. Like anyone really knows how to treat cancer."

Kate reached over and squeezed Paul's hand. She liked the way he kept his nails neatly trimmed. Matter of fact, she liked a lot of things about him. She noticed his tears but didn't comment. After awhile, he leaned over and kissed her lightly on the cheek.

"It just doesn't seem fair," she commented. "Susan's illness. I mean, she's one of the nicest people I know."

Paul nodded his head. Then he said, "I've thought a lot about things since she got sick."

"What kind of things?"

"You know, life and death, karma, benefits, religion…whether the Orioles will ever have another winning season."

Kate laughed. "No, seriously. I want to know what you've been thinking."

"Oh, I was just thinking about that song you like so much by the Vertigo Girls."

"Uh, Paul," she interrupted. "That's Indigo, not Vertigo."

"Really?" he asked.

"Absolutely. I listen to it sometimes when I'm waiting for you." She inserted a quarter from her purse into the jukebox on their table and selected the song called "Galileo."

And now I'm serving time for mistakes made by another in another lifetime how long till my soul gets it right can any human being ever reach that kind of light, I call on the resting soul of Galileo king of night vision, king of insight. — Indigo Girls from the song "Galileo"

They nursed their drinks while listening to the music. It had very moving lyrics about reincarnation and paying off karmic debt from past lifetimes. When the song ended, Kate said, "Paul, I've been chanting for three months. And while I have to admit to feeling happier than I've ever felt before, there are still so many things in my life I want to change. You've been practicing for over thirty years and you still have problems, too. I don't understand why I'm not getting all the benefits I want now if this practice really works."

"You mean," Paul added in a singing voice, "How long 'til your soul gets it right?"

"Yeah, I guess so," she said.

"That's what's amazing about this philosophy. It really does allow you to lessen your negative karma and to create good fortune in your life." Paul paused for Kate to consider what he had just said.

Inconspicuous benefit: Benefit that accumulates over a period of time and is not immediately recognizable. — from The Soka Gakkai Dictionary of Buddhism

Finally, she responded, "Lots of religions promise a better life in the future."

"Sure," he said, "And there are numerous self-help practices that result in near-term conspicuous benefits. Why, many people achieve great material goals just through hard work. But the real test of a religion is its ability to provide meaningful inconspicuous benefits over a long period of time—in this lifetime—not just after we die. And I would maintain that the most meaningful benefit I can have in my life is the satisfaction that, yes, I am progressing as a human being. That I have the courage and the wisdom to help others and myself when we are in difficult situations."

"And you think chanting does this?" she asked.

"I sure do. Nam-myoho-renge-kyo changes you at a very fundamental level, in a way that influences every aspect of your life…both body and mind."

"And soul?"

"I suspect so," he answered.

Kate thought about this for a moment and then declared, "Aren't you just making excuses for when good things don't happen?"

"It might look that way," Paul answered. "Still, we have to take responsibility for our own past causes…our own karma. I mean, I spent who knows how many lifetimes making just the right causes to become the confused person sitting before you today."

"You can say that again," she said.

"I'd rather not! Seriously, it's human nature to want everything now. I sure do. But the conspicuous benefits we so strongly desire, like better jobs, relationships and money give us the motivation to continue doing our human revolution while even more meaningful changes appear within our lives."

"Such as?" she asked.

"Well," Paul paused for a moment, "Take relationships. The fact that an incredibly beautiful and intelligent woman like you has continued to eat dinner with me for over three months proves that I must have changed something in my life. My previous affairs . . ."

"I beg your pardon," she interrupted indignantly.

"Sorry…poor choice of words. My previous relationships have been remarkably short and notable only for their lack of commitment. My sister claims I overanalyze every person I meet. But I've changed dramatically in other areas as well—my work habits, energy level and my ability to concentrate on matters at hand instead of always getting distracted. Just the fact I get up in the morning and look forward to the day. I even have reasonable conversations with my father."

Kate shook her head. "Lots of people have reasonable conversations with their parents, Paul, and they don't chant."

Paul nodded. "Hmm. I see your point. But it's like seeing someone who's an expert at something—a musician, for instance. It seems so effortless. We don't see the years of struggle, the countless times they may have almost given up and so it's difficult for us to understand how much they might have changed. Believe me when I tell you my life is radically different and happier than before I embraced this philosophy."

"That's what your sister said." Kate went on, "So what you're saying is that 'my soul can get it right this lifetime' through this practice…that it's the inconspicuous changes that occur over a long period of time that are the real lasting benefit?"

"Yeah," he replied, looking somewhat relieved.

In a teasing voice, Kate stated, "Why didn't you just say so?"

Benefit of the doubt: a favorable judgment granted in the absence of full evidence. —from The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition

"You know, Paul," she said, "I really can't say I completely believe in this yet."

"Me either," said Bea as she took a seat in the booth with Kate and Paul. "Mind if I join you? Have to wear earplugs not to hear most of what you're saying," she added as she poured herself a cup of coffee.

"That's okay," he muttered, "I'm perfectly happy to give you both the benefit of the doubt."

"Listen, sweetie," Bea said to Paul, "Can't say I really understand everything you two yap about on Friday nights and I don't mean to be nosy but maybe you should use that practice of yours to get the courage to call your sister…her being sick and all…and would either of you like a slice of warm apple pie?"

In unison, Paul and Kate nodded their heads, grinned, and asked, "With vanilla ice cream?"

Back to home

This article was included in Romancing the Buddha. Read the full book free as a Flipbook or find more essays by challenge.